Drum brake vs. disc brake: which one is more reliable?
On an e-scooter, brakes are among the most important safety systems of all. But which braking system is more reliable – drum brakes, disc brakes, or regenerative brakes? In this article, we explain how the brakes work, where their strengths lie, and why many manufacturers – including VMAX – use different systems depending on the model.
1. The drum brake – low-maintenance & reliable
The drum brake is a closed braking system. When braking, brake pads press from the inside against a rotating drum, causing friction which slows/stops the scooter. Because the system is fully enclosed, it is largely protected from water, dirt, and salt.
General note on mechanical brakes: Both drum and disc brakes can lose effectiveness during long downhill rides and continuous braking. This effect – often referred to as “glazing” – occurs when the braking surfaces harden due to constant heat build-up. That is exactly why engine braking is also used in cars on long mountain passes.
Advantages of the drum brake
- Very reliable in all weather conditions
- Hardly affected by dirt or moisture
- Very low maintenance
- Consistent braking feel
- Longer service life of braking components
Disadvantages of the drum brake
- Slightly lower braking performance than high-quality disc brakes
- Less “bite” during very sporty riding
All current VMAX models – e.g. VX2 PRO, VX2 EXTREME, VX4, and VX5 PRO – deliberately use drum brakes at the front, combined with regenerative brakes at the rear. This mix offers reliable, safe, and low-maintenance braking performance for everyday use.
2. The disc brake – high braking power & sporty character
With disc brakes, brake pads press against a rotating disc. This system provides very direct braking performance and is especially useful at higher speeds or with powerful motors.
Advantages of the disc brake
- Very high braking performance
- Direct, sporty brake response
- Ideal for high speeds or high peak power
Disadvantages of the disc brake
- Higher maintenance effort (adjustment, rubbing, wear)
- More sensitive to dirt, water, and salt
- Vulnerable to impacts or shocks, e.g. during transport or contact with a curb
- Can squeal or rub when dirty or not perfectly adjusted
Models with high peak power such as the VX2 Hub and VX4, NEW VX4, as well as the racing models R40 and R55, use an additional use disc brakes to provide maximum braking power in extreme riding situations.
3. Regenerative braking – efficient & wear-free
In addition to mechanical brakes, many modern e-scooters use an regenerative brake. Here, the motor itself slows the vehicle by reversing the current flow and recovering energy in the process.
How does recuperation braking work?
When braking, the motor acts like a generator. The resulting resistance slows the vehicle down, while helping recharge the battery. This ensures smooth, consistent deceleration – without mechanical wear.
Advantages of regenerative braking
- Completely wear-free
- Smooth, controlled braking
- Energy recovery while riding
- Supports the main brake and reduces wear on its components
Limits of regenerative brakes
- Less powerful than mechanical brakes
- Limited availability when the battery is fully charged
- Not a replacement for a strong front brake
Important to know: Depending on the setting, regenerative brakes can be very strong and, on some models, can even be more powerful from high speeds than the mechanical rear brake. However, its effect decreases as rotational speed drops. Even with a fully charged battery, recuperation remains functional, dissipating excess energy as heat, rather than using that energy to recharge the already-full battery.
Regenerative brakes are used on all modern VMAX models – as an intelligent complement to the front drum or disc brake. This provides greater safety, less wear, and a consistent braking feel.
4. So which braking system is more reliable?
There is no one-size-fits-all answer – both systems have clear strengths. The most reliable solution is often a combination of a mechanical front brake and a rear regenerative brake, as used on many VMAX e-scooters.
Drum brake + regenerative brakes
✓ Suitable for everyday use
✓ Low maintenance
✓ Very reliable
✓ Ideal for commuters
Disc brake + regenerative brake
✓ Maximum braking performance
✓ Optimal for powerful motors
✓ Precise control
✓ Ideal for sporty riding
5. FAQ
Which brake is best for everyday use?
For daily use, drum brakes are very reliable because they require little maintenance and are weather-resistant. Combined with regen, they form a strong and safe overall package, which in many cases can last the life of your scooter.
Why do some VMAX models use disc brakes?
Models with high peak power or a sporty focus benefit from the stronger braking performance and smaller lever-effort offered by disc brakes. That’s why they are used, for example, on the VX2 Hub, VX4, NEW VX4, R40, and R55.
Can regenerative braking replace a mechanical brake?
No. It supports braking but never completely replaces the main brake. Mechanical brakes remain essential for emergency and full braking.
Discover VMAX e-scooters
Find the model that suits your riding style – with reliable brakes and modern technology.
View all models